Merchant guides
Nutraceutical merchant accounts: why supplement sellers get flagged, and what underwriters check
Supplement and wellness sellers get labeled high risk for three reasons. Here’s what they are, what the card brands expect if you bill on a schedule, and what an underwriter will ask you for.
Why nutra gets flagged.
A nutraceutical merchant account is a card processing account for businesses that sell supplements, wellness products, CBD, kratom and similar items. Processors label most of these sellers high risk. That label doesn’t mean you did anything wrong. It means the category has a history of chargebacks, and the bank that carries your account is on the hook if those chargebacks pile up.
- Product claims.Labels and ads that promise health results draw complaints and refund requests. Underwriters read your site before they read your bank statements.
- Subscriptions.Auto-ship and “free trial, then monthly” offers are a common source of disputes in this space. A customer who forgot they signed up calls their bank, not you.
- Chargeback math.Since April 1, 2026, Visa’s monitoring program (VAMP) flags a US merchant as “Excessive” once fraud reports plus disputes reach 1.5% of its settled card-not-present transactions (a count of transactions, not dollars), with a minimum of 1,500 of those events in a month. The line was 2.2% before that date. Merchants in the Excessive tier can be charged a fee on every dispute, and the processor often adds reserves or closes the account before it gets that far.
Recurring billing, and what underwriters look at.
If you bill on a schedule, the rules are stricter than for one-time orders.
Mastercard’s subscription standards, in effect since September 22, 2022, ask merchants to make the terms clear at signup, send a confirmation email at enrollment, send a receipt after every charge, offer a way to cancel online, and, for any plan billed less often than every six months (an annual subscription, for example), send a reminder 7 to 30 days before the next charge.
The FTC’s “click to cancel” rule from 2024 was thrown out by a federal appeals court in July 2025, before it took effect. That didn’t end the issue. The older federal Negative Option Rule still applies, the FTC keeps bringing cases under ROSCA, and in March 2026 it opened a new rulemaking on negative option billing. Build your checkout as if click-to-cancel were law: plain terms, the price and billing date before the card is charged, and a cancel button as easy to find as the signup button.
When you apply, expect to be asked for:
- Processing statements.Three to six months, if you’ve taken cards before.
- Your website.Product pages, terms, refund policy and a working contact page.
- Certificates of analysis.For CBD, kratom or anything sold by potency.
- Your subscription flow.Screen by screen, if you bill on a schedule.
- Your chargeback and refund rates.Current numbers, not estimates.
Clean answers on these move an application faster than anything else.
Flow State Merchant Services sets up processing for smoke, vape, CBD and kratom shops, the same underwriting world as nutra. If you sell supplements alongside those, we can tell you up front which documents an underwriter will want and what your subscription flow needs before you apply.
Sources: Justt: Visa VAMP’s tighter threshold is now live (Apr 2026) · Checkout.com: new Mastercard standards for subscriptions · Kelley Drye: FTC relaunches negative option rulemaking (Mar 2026)
Want us to check your statement?
Upload last month’s statement with a quick form and we’ll show you your effective rate, line by line. Free.
FAQ
Common questions
Can I use Stripe, Square or PayPal for supplements?
What chargeback rate is too high?
Do I need a rolling reserve?
Work with us
Get your rate quote.
Two minutes on the form with your latest statement attached. You get a straight answer.